Pre-Workout Supplements: What Works and What’s Just Hype

Disclosure: Vitae List is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Introduction: The Hype Behind the Scoop

You’ve probably seen them — brightly colored tubs promising explosive energy, laser focus, and unreal pumps. Pre-workout supplements dominate the shelves of gyms and online stores, but not all are created equal. The truth? Some formulas deliver a measurable boost in performance… while others rely on caffeine and clever marketing.

Let’s break down what actually works — and what’s just hype — so you can train smarter and spend your money wisely.

What Pre-Workouts Are Designed to Do

At their best, pre-workouts are formulated to:

• Increase energy and alertness

• Enhance blood flow and muscle pump

• Improve endurance and strength output

• Support focus and motivation

But here’s the catch: the right ingredients in the right doses are what make the difference. Many products underdose key compounds or overload you with stimulants instead of performance-driven nutrients.

The Ingredients That Actually Work

Let’s look at the research-backed players in the pre-workout game:

1. Caffeine

✅ What it does: Boosts alertness, energy, and power output.
⚖️ Dose: 3–6 mg per kg of body weight (typically 150–300 mg per serving).
⚠️ Tip: Too much caffeine can cause jitters, anxiety, or a post-workout crash.

2. Creatine Monohydrate

✅ What it does: Enhances strength, power, and recovery over time.
⚖️ Dose: 3–5 g daily (can be taken pre- or post-workout).
💡 Note: Some pre-workouts add creatine, but standalone supplementation is more reliable for consistent dosing.

3. Beta-Alanine

✅ What it does: Buffers lactic acid buildup, improving endurance during high-intensity training.
⚖️ Dose: 2–5 g daily.
💡 Heads-up: That tingling sensation (paresthesia) is harmless — and a sign it’s working.

4. L-Citrulline / Citrulline Malate

✅ What it does: Increases nitric oxide levels for better blood flow and “pump.”
⚖️ Dose: 6–8 g per serving (of L-citrulline, not citrulline malate).

5. Tyrosine & Theanine

✅ What they do: Support focus and smooth out caffeine’s harsh effects.
💡 Why it matters: These ingredients help you stay locked in without overstimulation.

Finding the right brand with the right stack of clearly identified ingredients is difficult to navigate but we will make it easy. Nutricost has several different types of pre--workouts depending on what you hope to get from it. Also they clearly identify each ingredient and what its composition is as opposed to hiding their ingredients in "proprietary blends". We like these two offerings: the first being a pre-workout with caffeine/ stimulant and the second being a stimulant free version incase you like to workout at night like we do.

• Nutricost Pre-X Xtreme Pre-Workout Complex Powder - https://amzn.to/47kmNyq

• Nutricost Stim-Free Pre-Workout - https://amzn.to/3IP69id

What’s Mostly Marketing Hype

Not everything that glows on the label delivers results. Here’s what’s often overstated:

🚫 “Pump” blends with mystery ingredients – Many include underdosed or unproven nitric oxide boosters.

🚫 Proprietary blends – Hide actual dosages, making it impossible to know what you’re getting.

🚫 Over-the-top stimulants – Mega doses of caffeine or exotic stimulants can boost heart rate but don’t necessarily improve performance.

🚫 Buzzword fillers – Ingredients like BCAAs, taurine, or glutamine in small amounts add label appeal, not real benefit.

How to Choose a Pre-Workout That Works

Here’s what to look for on the label:

✅ Transparent ingredients – No proprietary blends; every dose listed.
✅ Science-backed compounds – Caffeine, citrulline, creatine, and beta-alanine are proven performers.
✅ Moderate stimulant levels – Enough to energize, not overwhelm.
✅ Clean formulation – Skip artificial dyes and sweeteners if possible.

Pro Tip: You can even DIY your pre-workout by combining caffeine (from coffee), creatine, and citrulline powder — cheaper and more customizable.

When and How to Take Pre-Workout

Timing is key.

• Take your pre-workout 20–40 minutes before training to allow for absorption.

• Hydrate well — stimulants can increase water loss.

• Avoid taking late in the day to prevent sleep disruption.

If you train often, consider cycling off caffeine every few weeks to reset your tolerance.

Bottom Line: Smart Fuel Beats Flashy Formulas

The best pre-workouts aren’t about the craziest label or the strongest “buzz.” They’re about giving your body the right fuel to perform better.

Stick with clinically dosed ingredients, transparent labels, and products that align with your training goals. When you know what works — caffeine, creatine, citrulline, and beta-alanine — you’ll lift stronger and recover faster without falling for hype.

Key Takeaway:
Pre-workouts should amplify your training — not just your heart rate. Choose smart, dose right, and fuel your lifts with purpose.